Motion to Suppress Evidence in Assault Trials

A How-To Guide for Excluding Unlawful or Prejudicial Evidence in Texas Assault Cases

When you’ve been charged with assault or aggravated assault in Texas, most people assume the trial will simply be a matter of presenting evidence and letting the jury decide guilt or innocence. But there’s a critical legal tool that can shape — or even end — the case before it gets to that point: the motion to suppress evidence.

A motion to suppress is one of the most powerful defense strategies in a Texas criminal case. If the court grants the motion, certain key pieces of the State’s evidence may be ruled inadmissible at trial. And without that evidence, the prosecution may have no choice but to reduce or dismiss the charges altogether.

In this post, we’ll explain what a motion to suppress is, when it’s used in assault trials, common grounds for suppression, and how a criminal defense attorney near you can use it to defend your rights.

What Is a Motion to Suppress?

A motion to suppress is a formal legal request by the defense asking the court to exclude specific evidence from being used at trial, usually because it was:

• Illegally obtained
• Unconstitutionally acquired
• Unreliable or unauthenticated
• Overly prejudicial

In Texas assault cases, motions to suppress are commonly filed before trial during the pretrial phase, and a judge — not a jury — decides whether the evidence will be allowed.

See: Challenging the Evidence in Assault Investigations

When Can a Motion to Suppress Be Filed?

Your attorney near you may file a motion to suppress any time there’s a legal basis to challenge the way evidence was collected, handled, or introduced. These motions are usually filed after discovery is received but before the first day of trial.

The court will then schedule a pretrial hearing, where both sides can present arguments and, in some cases, witnesses or expert testimony.

Common Grounds to Suppress Evidence in Assault Cases

There are multiple legal grounds your attorney may use to seek suppression:

1. Illegal Search and Seizure (Fourth Amendment)

If police seized evidence without a warrant, without consent, or without legal justification, the evidence may be inadmissible. This includes:

• Cell phone searches
• Entry into your home
• Collection of surveillance footage from private property
• Retrieval of medical records without authorization

2. Violation of Miranda Rights (Fifth Amendment)

If you were interrogated in custody without being read your Miranda rights, your statements may be suppressed.

See: Police Misconduct or Rights Violations in Assault Cases

3. Unreliable Eyewitness Identification

Your criminal defense lawyer near you can challenge:

• Flawed photo arrays
• Suggestive lineups
• In-court identifications not preceded by proper procedures

These challenges are often supported by motions to suppress the identification itself.

See: Mistaken Identity in Assault Arrests

4. Improper Collection of Digital Evidence

If police obtained social media posts, texts, emails, or phone data without proper warrants or consent, the defense may argue for suppression under Tex. Code Crim. Proc. Art. 38.23 (evidence obtained in violation of law).

5. Lack of Authentication (Tex. R. Evid. 901)

If the State cannot properly authenticate video, documents, or electronic communications, your attorney can object and move to suppress it as unreliable or unauthenticated evidence.

6. Prejudicial Evidence (Tex. R. Evid. 403)

Even if evidence is relevant, it may be excluded if its unfair prejudice outweighs its probative value. For example:

• Graphic injury photos not necessary for the issue at hand
• Hearsay statements offered as fact
• Prior unrelated bad acts offered to sway the jury emotionally

What Happens During a Suppression Hearing?

At a suppression hearing, the defense and prosecution present evidence and arguments to the judge. Your attorney may:

• Cross-examine officers about the arrest or evidence collection
• Introduce case law or procedural violations
• Present expert witnesses or technical analysis
• Argue constitutional violations under federal and state law

If the judge agrees, the evidence is excluded from trial entirely — which can dramatically alter the strength of the prosecution’s case.

Can a Suppression Motion Lead to Dismissal?

Yes. In many assault cases, if the court suppresses a key piece of evidence — such as a confession, surveillance footage, or identification — the prosecution may lose the ability to prove its case and be forced to:

• Dismiss the charges outright
• Offer a favorable plea deal
• Reduce the charges significantly

See: How Early Legal Counsel Can Influence the Outcome of Your Case

What If the Suppression Motion Is Denied?

Even if your motion is denied, the suppression hearing can:

• Provide early insight into the State’s trial strategy
• Lock officers into testimony for later impeachment
• Create appellate issues if you are convicted
• Lay groundwork for renewed challenges during trial

A skilled criminal defense attorney near you will use every opportunity to protect your rights — even when suppression is denied.

Strategic Timing of Suppression Motions

Timing matters. Your attorney may file suppression motions:

• Before discovery (based on known violations)
• After discovery (once evidence issues are identified)
• As part of plea negotiations (to pressure the State to resolve the case)
• During trial, if new evidence surfaces or new objections arise

The earlier these motions are raised, the more options your defense team has to reshape the case.

Final Thoughts: Suppression Is One of Your Strongest Tools

In Texas assault trials, a motion to suppress is not just a legal formality — it’s often a turning point in the entire case. Whether the issue is unlawful search, rights violations, or prejudicial evidence, your criminal defense attorney near you can file pretrial motions that change the outcome before a jury ever hears a word.

Don’t assume the State’s evidence is untouchable. With the right legal strategy, much of it can be excluded — and when that happens, your chances of dismissal or acquittal rise dramatically.

Call Walker Law Office today at (713) 228-2611 or visit https://www.walkerlawhouston.com/contact/ to speak with an experienced attorney near you who can file strategic suppression motions and protect your rights in court.

‍